Kopp and Diridon Eat Crow

On December 3rd, the California High-Speed Rail Authority unanimously voted to rescind their certification of the Final EIR for the Bay Area to Central Valley HSR Project, along with the selection of the Pacheco Pass alignment. The CAHSRA was ordered to take these actions by the Sacramento Superior Court, which had found the EIR to be legally inadequate. This is the same case Quentin Kopp had disparaged in the press as "frivolous."

Our allies, the CA Rail Foundation, issued this press release. The San Jose Business Journal published the key quote from the release: "He describes the high-speed rail proposal as "so badly bungled that, despite spending $250 million to date, there is still no feasible project on the horizon."

This truthtelling so infuriated Robert Cruickshank, chief apologist for the CAHSRA, that he wrote an entire blog attacking the press release. It turns out that Mr. Cruickshank actually doesn't understand the legalities of what he so ardently professes. See the TRANSDEF response at the bottom of the blog.

The attorney for the plaintiffs wrote an analysis of the significance of the Court's decision that led to the recission vote.